Daimler cannot be sued under Alien Tort Statute, says US judge

Article by Anita Panait, on December 29, 2013

United States District Judge Shira Scheindlin in New York has ruled that Daimler AG and Rheinmetall AG cannot be held liable for allegedly aiding and abetting the South African government during the apartheid. The companies, along with Ford and IBM, were accused of facilitating race-based crimes by selling vehicles and computers to South African security forces during the apartheid.

Judge Scheindlin, however, ruled that the German companies could not be sued under a 1789 law -- the Alien Tort Statute -- allowing non-US citizens to bring cases in US courts over violations of international law. According to Scheindlin, plaintiffs failed to show that the facts of the case "touch and concern the United States with sufficient force" to justify the law's use.

She, however, did not immediately dismiss related claims against Ford and IBM. The companies had bid for a dismissal after a federal appeals court in August 2013 sent the case back to Scheindlin for a decision, while opining that the claims appeared "plainly barred" by a recent Supreme Court ruling.

Plaintiffs include South Africans and family members who claimed they were victims of race-based crimes, including torture and extrajudicial killings, by South African security during the apartheid, which ended on 1994 when the country conducted its first all-race elections. Both Robert Zimet, a lawyer for Rheinmettal, and Han Tjan, a spokesman for Daimler, welcomed the ruling.

"We are hopeful that this ruling will put a final end to this litigation that went on for over 10 years," Tjan remarked. Scheindlin's order is the latest result of a US Supreme Court decision that limited the ability of human rights plaintiffs to use the Alien Tort Statute to file lawsuits against companies for alleged improper collusion with foreign governments.

Topics: daimler, lawsuit

If you liked the article, share on:

Comments

Recommended

Is there anything more exciting than a spoiler? Well, for those who didn't know, there are those who have already seen the Mercedes-AMG Project One (in the flesh) way before...
by - April 25, 2017
Does the Honda Passport ring a bell to you? This was the first ever SUV that was sold by the Japanese automaker, but it was not that successful compared with...
by - April 25, 2017
Wagon buyers who prefer their vehicle to be luxurious, you will have an entirely brand new selection at the latter part of this year. Porsche will start rolling out 4...
by - April 25, 2017
McLaren rejects the idea of creating anything other than a sports car. That means that vehicles that would be ideal for families such as an SUV or a crossover are...
by - April 25, 2017
The new and improved Opel Grandland X is out, and this large SUV is something the European market did not know they would need. Now measuring at 14.7 feet (4.48...
by - April 25, 2017
Facebook

Youtube Channel

Tip Us
Do you have a tip for us?
Did you film an important event?
Contact us
Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter!
Subscribe
Galleries