GM recall still not as bad as Toyota’s case 4 years ago

Article by Christian Andrei, on March 20, 2014

General Motors’ ignition switch recall reminds of a similar action taken by Toyota four years ago over unintended-acceleration issues. Despite having only four casualties linked to the issue compared to GM’s 12, Toyota’s recall is considered as the benchmark immense recall of this time – because of the controversy it sparked as well as its scope and impact.

In GM’s case, the carmaker was able to determine the root cause of the recall from the start – faulty ignition switch. In Toyota’s case, the root cause was uncertain. At first, engineers suspected that trapped pedals cause vehicles to accelerate unintentionally.

They later said that the cause was sticky pedals. Skeptics, on the hand, suspect faulty electronics and claimed that Toyota was covering up big time. However, a study by NHTSA and NASA failed to prove the faulty electronics theory, although Toyota’s critics still adopt to the ghost-in-the-machine thesis, especially in current lawsuits.

The changing theories on what caused the unintended acceleration in Toyota’s small vehicles led to customer distrust and pandemonium. Following the first recall in the fall of 2009, NHTSA received tons of complaints, reaching its peak in the first quarter of 2010 at over 1,400 disgruntled owners. Prior to that, monthly complaints average at fewer than 50 from early 2004 through October 2009.

GM, however, is not experiencing similar events. Of course, the effects of faulty airbags could only be experienced when a driver crashes his unit. On the other than, unintended acceleration could be felt while driving, giving drivers a “feeling” of pedal misapplication, “unnatural” revving of the engine.

Shortly after the 2009 recall, Toyota has started recalling vehicles globally for all sorts of issues, sending the Japanese carmaker down in terms of quality perception and sales.

If you liked the article, share on:

Comments

Login or Create new account to add a comment!

Recommended

More positive news has been pouring in before the year ends. For those who have been waiting to hear the latest word on Toyota 86, we have some great news....
by - December 10, 2016
Hyundai is making the green vehicle race more competitive by offering three powertrain types -- pure electric (EV), hybrid (EV plus combustion engine) and plug-in hybrid (PHEV) – in one...
by - December 9, 2016
Although specs for the new Renault Megane had already surfaced several weeks ago, we didn’t know that the company has cooked up something new. Aside from the 200hp gasoline, Renault‘s...
by - December 9, 2016
For the first time in fifty-eight years, Infiniti registers its first US-Spec Q60 Coupe in Cuba. American products have not been allowed entry into Cuba for six decades. But it...
by - December 9, 2016
Chevrolet has already given out the pricing for some of its 2018 Equinox models. Not only will the new Equinox be available in both the US and Canada, it is...
by - December 9, 2016
Facebook

Youtube Channel

Tip Us
Do you have a tip for us?
Did you film an important event?
Contact us
Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter!
Subscribe
Galleries