Judge said that Toyota can’t force named plaintiffs to arbitrate their claims

Article by Christian Andrei, on February 27, 2012

A tentative court ruling states that Toyota Motor Corp. can't compel plaintiffs to arbitrate their claims instead of proceeding to trial in a supposed class-action lawsuit over losses from unintentional sudden acceleration. Last Friday, U.S. District Judge James Selna in Santa Ana, Calif., stated that Toyota waived its right to compel arbitration for 15 of the 20 plaintiffs and that, for the five plaintiffs left, Toyota wasn't a party to the arbitration agreements between the plaintiffs and the Toyota dealers.

There is a hearing set on Feb. 27 in federal court in Santa Ana for Toyota's lawyers to attempt to convince the judge to change his decision.

In the tentative order, Judge Selna said that by failing to assert a right to compel arbitration until today, Toyota has “encouraged plaintiffs to pursue their current litigation strategy, including pursuing their claims on a class-wide basis in a federal forum.”

He said that if the claims were required to be submitted to arbitration now, these would be prejudiced. Selna has presided over the consolidated litigation since 2010.

He has set three trials for 2013 that will serve as bellwether cases, which the court and the lawyers could use to test evidence and liability theories before proceeding to other trials and a ruling by Selna on whether to approve a class-action status for the plaintiffs.

Toyota's request for majority of the economic loss cases to be sent to arbitration was based on the company’s argument that customers who purchased or leased Toyota vehicles involved in the litigation inked arbitration agreements that waive their rights to join a class-action case. [source: Autonews]

Topics: toyota

If you liked the article, share on:

Comments

Login or Create new account to add a comment!

Recommended

The Shooting Brake is probably the least rendered body shape in the automotive world. But it’s also the most sought after design among car nuts for its unique, old-fashioned charm....
by - January 23, 2017
Perhaps to make the upcoming Valentine’s day more special, Tinder dating app and Ford UK have cooked up a special blind date for all the single blokes and chicks in...
by - January 23, 2017
2017 is undeniably a very busy year for BMW. After introducing the new 4-Series, the German automaker has just released several new updates. In relation to this, BMW is also...
by - January 23, 2017
The renowned Shelby Super Snake is now 50 years old! As we greet the Super Snake a “happy birthday” or a “happy anniversary,” Shelby itself is celebrating half a century...
by - January 23, 2017
Nearly a year after the Subaru XV Concept was unveiled at the 2016 Geneva Motor Show in Switzerland, this SUV study is making its North American debut at the 2017...
by - January 23, 2017
Facebook

Youtube Channel

Tip Us
Do you have a tip for us?
Did you film an important event?
Contact us
Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter!
Subscribe
Galleries