Nissan dealers helped by Chevrolet vehicle assembly plant to keep its franchise

Article by Christian A., on August 30, 2012

Ohio’s Franklin County Court of Common Pleas favored a Nissan dealer in its ruling that a Chevrolet vehicle assembly plant near the dealership is adversely affecting how it performs. The Ohio court’s ruling could set a precedence for other auto dealerships found in distinctly challenging markets. It brings to light a legal dilemma regarding the plant’s practice of comparing how auto dealerships in dissimilar markets perform.

The issue raised by Nissan dealer Bill Sims, whose showroom is in Warren, Ohio, is not against General Motors but rather, it is with Nissan North America, which tried to terminate his franchise after naming his as the owner of the worst-performing Nissan store in the 13-state region.

Sims is a Buick-GMC dealer who had taken over the local Nissan store in 2001 after its former owner left. Nissan didn’t consider Sims’ point that GM’s nearby Lordstown assembly plant, had to be perceived as a challenge that restricts his Nissan market penetration. The plant’s 4,500 workers currently assemble the Chevrolet Cruze. It also built the Chevy Cobalt and Cavalier for several years in the past.

Sims got warnings from Nissan for his failure to meet factory performance standards. Nissan then decided to terminate his franchise in 2009. Sims complained to the Ohio Motor Vehicle Dealers Board that it was not fair to compare his results against the performance of Nissan dealers in markets that didn’t have a GM assembly plant.

Sims asserted that GM offers special vehicle discounts to Lordstown employees, their family members and friends, and thousands of GM retirees in the area. Chevrolet’s local market share is double the average recorded for the state. On the other hand, Toyota, Nissan and Honda’s sales are about half of the normal state average. [source: Automotive News - sub. required]

Topics: nissan, dealer, chevrolet

If you liked the article, share on:

Comments

Recommended

Is there anything more exciting than a spoiler? Well, for those who didn't know, there are those who have already seen the Mercedes-AMG Project One (in the flesh) way before...
by - April 25, 2017
Does the Honda Passport ring a bell to you? This was the first ever SUV that was sold by the Japanese automaker, but it was not that successful compared with...
by - April 25, 2017
Wagon buyers who prefer their vehicle to be luxurious, you will have an entirely brand new selection at the latter part of this year. Porsche will start rolling out 4...
by - April 25, 2017
McLaren rejects the idea of creating anything other than a sports car. That means that vehicles that would be ideal for families such as an SUV or a crossover are...
by - April 25, 2017
The new and improved Opel Grandland X is out, and this large SUV is something the European market did not know they would need. Now measuring at 14.7 feet (4.48...
by - April 25, 2017
Facebook

Youtube Channel

Tip Us
Do you have a tip for us?
Did you film an important event?
Contact us
Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter!
Subscribe
Galleries