Texas jury awards $136 million to Mercedes-Benz dealer over deception

Article by Anita Panait, on February 26, 2013

A dealer for Mercedes-Benz USA (MBUSA) who alleged that the carmaker misled him to believe that he could move a store he acquired for $7 million to a more promising location was awarded $136 million by a jury in a district court in Cameron County, Texas. Renato Cardenas Sr., the owner of Carduco Inc. and Cardenas Metroplex, a Mercedes dealership in Harlingen, Texas, claimed that from 2008 to 2009, officials of the carmaker encouraged him to buy the Harlingen dealership and even visited proposed sites for it in McAllen, Texas.

Expecting that he could move the dealership to McAllen and build a new store, Cardenas acquired the franchise in Harlingen.

Cardenas alleged that the carmaker secretly awarded an open point in McAllen to rival dealer Ron Heller, owner of Heller-Bird Motors of Mission, Texas. Cardenas claimed that Mercedes undertook "active steps to conceal its intentions and deliberately provided false and misleading information in order to deceive Carduco." Court documents said that previous owners of the Harlingen dealership, Carduco and Mercedes had "multiple discussions" about the acquisition for 14 months.

The suit said that at every opportunity, Cardenas informed MBUSA that he intends to move the Harlingen-based dealership to McAllen, upon the approval of his dealership application. The suit contended that Mercedes did not disclose that the open point had been awarded to Heller until after Cardenas finalized his purchase in June 2009. The complaint was filed in June 2011 by Renato Cardenas Sr. The jury reached the decision on Feb. 15, 2013. Mercedes says it will appeal the ruling.

If you liked the article, share on:

Comments

Login or Create new account to add a comment!

Recommended

The bidding war for one of the only 20 examples -- 21 actually, but the 00 version went to a museum -- of the classically beautiful Lamborghini Reventon built and...
by - January 18, 2017
Bentley once again confirmed its plans to push PHEV into their future lineups. As a matter of fact, the Bentayga SUV will be the first to have the plugin hybrid...
by - January 18, 2017
Each time that Mini launches a new generation of the Countryman crossover, a John Cooper Works performance version is always expected to follow. When Mini unveiled the next-gen 2017 Mini...
by - January 18, 2017
Ford Mustang customers won’t be able to specify the V6 powerplant for the latest iteration of the carmaker’s pony car. This comes as the new 2018 Ford Mustang is saying...
by - January 18, 2017
The man sitting at the top of the performance division of Mercedes-Benz – Tobias Moers – cryptically indicated that the Mercedes-AMG GT4 could be really coming. Moers, chief executive of...
by - January 18, 2017
Facebook

Youtube Channel

Tip Us
Do you have a tip for us?
Did you film an important event?
Contact us
Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter!
Subscribe
Galleries