Toyota won tentative dismissal of several acceleration claims

Article by Andrew Christian, on April 24, 2012

Several claims of Toyota vehicle owners, who alleged that the value of their units dropped due to the massive recalls for unintentional acceleration, were dismissed. The tentative order was given by U.S. District Judge James Selna in Santa Ana, Calif., who agreed with Toyota that the claims can’t be brought under the states’ laws by the New York and Florida class representatives in the consolidated lawsuits if they didn't allege that their cars experienced sudden, unintended acceleration.

The judge also ruled against Toyota and asserted that New York law didn't preclude a plaintiff’s claims that she traded in her Prius for a lower amount due to the alleged defect even if she didn't claim that her car demonstrated the defect.

Selna will make a final ruling on Toyota's request to junk the claims after its April 23 hearing.

Selna said that it would be likely that the highest court of the state New York would find actionable the claims of a “plaintiff who realizes a measurable loss on the resale or trade-in of a vehicle with an unmanifested defect that may be fairly attributed to that defect."

According further to the judge's tentative ruling, the issue of whether New York and Florida law permitted claims for "unmanifested" defects is a separate question from whether plaintiffs who didn’t experience sudden, unintended acceleration problems with their vehicles had the right to sue.

Last year, Selna said that Toyota owners were in a legal position to sue for alleged economic losses and then permitted Toyota to challenge his decision with the U.S. Court of Appeals in San Francisco. [source: Bloomberg]

If you liked the article, share on:

Comments

Login or Create new account to add a comment!

You may also be interested

What to read next

BMW is currently one of the leading electric vehicle (EV) manufacturers. It has established its sub-brand, the BMW i, in 2011 that caters to the design and manufacture of these...
by - May 25, 2016
The 2016 Concorso d’Eleganza Villa d’Este has been chosen as the venue to unveil a special model that pays tribute to BMW 2002 turbo – the BMW 2002 Hommage. This...
by - May 23, 2016
Volvo, one of the world’s foremost automotive manufacturers, introduced two new small concept cars today, signalling the Swedish company’s venturesome leap into the international small-car market. The introduction of the...
by - May 23, 2016
Aston Martin together with their longtime Italian partner for design Zagato are proclaiming their fifth and latest collaborative exhibition vehicle, the Vanquish Zagato Concept, which was ceremonially launched on May...
by - May 23, 2016
MINI is heralding the arrival of the latest iteration of the MINI John Cooper Works Convertible, offering to deliver intense driving dynamics and exhilarating open-air riding pleasure. Created to accommodate...
by - May 22, 2016