Daimler, VW and BMW to return awards to ADAC

Article by Anita Panait, on February 15, 2014

German carmakers Daimler, Volkswagen and BMW will return awards received from auto club ADAC following discovery of results manipulation for the "Yellow Angel" award by an external audit conducted by Deloitte. An audit of the award procedures was conducted by Deloitte after claims surfaced in January that ADAC's Motorwelt magazine had inflated readership votes.

ADAC had said that 34,299 motorists voted for the “Yellow Angel” award, which is given to the most popular car in Germany. According to Deloitte, it had found evidence of "willful manipulation" as well as technologically flawed processing of data. The audit discovered that the order of four of the first five places had been manipulated.

For instance, BMW's 3-series car should have been second behind the VW Golf based on votes submitted. However, the 3-series did not even make it into the top five. While the Golf was the rightful winner of the award, the Audi A3 was wrongly placed as No. 2 and the Mercedes A Class was wrongly placed at No. 3.

Deloitte discovered that 3,271 votes were for the Golf; 1,703 for the BMW 3 series; 1,664 for the Audi A3; 1,320 for the Mercedes A Class; and 1,184 for the Skoda Octavia. ADAC initially said that only the total number of votes had been manipulated but not the order. During its audit, Deloitte examined computer data and conducted interviews with ADAC employees.

Deloitte said the former director of ADAC communications, Peter Ramstetter, had simulated different scenarios on his computer on how the number and order of the votes could be manipulated. According to ADAC, Deloitte would now examine the voting in the years 2005 until 2013 after finding similarities in how the “Yellow Angel” prize had been awarded.

If you liked the article, share on:

Topics: daimler, vw, bmw

Comments

Recommended

At Aston Martin, there is the Valkyrie. In the near future, there might also be a Valhalla. Another name that starts with letter “V,” the Valhalla has just been reserved...
by - November 16, 2018
The up-and-coming Audi E-tron GT four-door sports car is one of the electric cars that the premium carmaker has promised to deliver before 2025. But as early as now, some...
by - November 15, 2018
Magneti Marelli S.p.A., the high-end maker of automotive parts and components, will be soon own by a Japanese company. This comes as it current owner, Fiat Chrysler Automobiles has inked...
by - November 15, 2018
It has already been months since Czech carmaker Skoda unveiled the comprehensively refreshed – both in terms of design and engineering -- Fabia hatchback. Now, the car company will be...
by - November 14, 2018
After VIN registrations revealed months ago that Porsche was planning a new 718 Cayman T, new details have surfaced that about the hardcore model. According to a report by Auto...
by - November 14, 2018