Toyota win dismissal of most claims by Florida and New York regarding unintended acceleration

Article by Christian A., on May 6, 2012

Toyota Motor Corp. can’t be sued for economic loss by car owners in Florida who didn’t actually experience an unintended acceleration event, according to last Friday’s ruling by U.S. District Judge James Selna in Santa Ana, Calif. that finalizes last April’s tentative decision. He also ruled that New York plaintiffs can’t sue if this didn’t occur to them or if they didn’t experience a measurable loss when attempting to sell or trade in their vehicles.

The court dismissed most claims by Florida and New York car owners who asserted that Toyota reduced their vehicles’ value by its failure to divulge or repair defects related to unintended acceleration.

Carl Tobias, law professor at the University of Richmond in Virginia, believes that the decision will have an impact on “most” of the economic loss claims in those states. He said that assembling a class would be harder since there would be considerably fewer eligible parties. At the hearing on April 23, lawyers for Toyota and the plaintiffs said that the ruling could remove millions of vehicle owners from the litigation.

In an earlier decision, Selna said that California plaintiffs could file a suit for economic loss even if have never experienced an unintended acceleration incident. Last June, Selna said that California law can’t be used by car owners in other states to pursue their claims.

Steve Berman, a lead lawyer for plaintiffs claiming economic loss, expressed disappointment that Judge Selna is requiring that to sue, the class members have to “drive ticking time bombs.” He said that this matter will be brought to the highest courts in Florida and New York, considering that Toyota hasn’t been able to repair “thousands of crashes” that have led to “hundreds of deaths.”

If you liked the article, share on:

Comments

Recommended

Bimmerpost has posted several cool pictures of the new BMW G30 540i and the new G31 generation BMW 5-Series Touring, with both wearing the brilliant Rhodonite Silver Individual colour. The...
by - October 23, 2017
A few years ago, Lotus tried to take on Porsche. They had a five-car plan to go against competitors like Ferrari and Aston Martin. Though it did not go well,...
by - October 23, 2017
To keep the Nissan Maxima interesting, the Japanese automaker gives the 2018 model year a number of small tweaks. Some of these include standard Android Auto, which is a new...
by - October 23, 2017
It looks as if Chevrolet has everything planned out in terms of production. Firstly, they have plans of introducing the Corvette ZR1 in a few months, which will then be...
by - October 23, 2017
While Tesla Motors continues to struggle with regards to the assembly of its much awaited Tesla Model 3, investment firm Oppenheimer & Co. is confident that its previous production estimates...
by - October 22, 2017
Facebook

Youtube Channel

Tip Us
Do you have a tip for us?
Did you film an important event?
Contact us
Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter!
Subscribe
Galleries