Toyota won tentative dismissal of several acceleration claims

Article by Christian A., on April 24, 2012

Several claims of Toyota vehicle owners, who alleged that the value of their units dropped due to the massive recalls for unintentional acceleration, were dismissed. The tentative order was given by U.S. District Judge James Selna in Santa Ana, Calif., who agreed with Toyota that the claims can’t be brought under the states’ laws by the New York and Florida class representatives in the consolidated lawsuits if they didn't allege that their cars experienced sudden, unintended acceleration.

The judge also ruled against Toyota and asserted that New York law didn't preclude a plaintiff’s claims that she traded in her Prius for a lower amount due to the alleged defect even if she didn't claim that her car demonstrated the defect.

Selna will make a final ruling on Toyota's request to junk the claims after its April 23 hearing.

Selna said that it would be likely that the highest court of the state New York would find actionable the claims of a “plaintiff who realizes a measurable loss on the resale or trade-in of a vehicle with an unmanifested defect that may be fairly attributed to that defect."

According further to the judge's tentative ruling, the issue of whether New York and Florida law permitted claims for "unmanifested" defects is a separate question from whether plaintiffs who didn’t experience sudden, unintended acceleration problems with their vehicles had the right to sue.

Last year, Selna said that Toyota owners were in a legal position to sue for alleged economic losses and then permitted Toyota to challenge his decision with the U.S. Court of Appeals in San Francisco. [source: Bloomberg]

If you liked the article, share on:

Comments

Recommended

While Tesla Motors continues to struggle with regards to the assembly of its much awaited Tesla Model 3, investment firm Oppenheimer & Co. is confident that its previous production estimates...
by - October 22, 2017
It seems that BMW’s high-performance division -- BMW M – still has not warmed up to front-wheel drive vehicles. So those who had been looking forward to BMW M vehicles...
by - October 22, 2017
Porsche already has the Performance Package for their range-topping Macan Turbo, which is currently available in some countries. Soon, this model will be dethroned by something even fancier by the...
by - October 22, 2017
After the highly dynamic Polestar 1 two-door coupe – Polestar’s first ever production car -- was recently unveiled, not a few people’s curiosity was piqued as to how much they...
by - October 21, 2017
The BMW 7 Series is already highly sought after but nonetheless, the German marque is giving it a more exclusive variant for the Russian market, and they are calling it...
by - October 20, 2017
Facebook

Youtube Channel

Tip Us
Do you have a tip for us?
Did you film an important event?
Contact us
Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter!
Subscribe
Galleries